/

Reviews

Reviews

How to Answer a One Star Review Without Losing Sleep

How to Answer a One Star Review Without Losing Sleep

How to Answer a One Star Review Without Losing Sleep

Only 7% of people do not expect a reply to their review. Here is a simple way for Hawaiʻi owners to answer the good, the bad, and the unfair.

Only 7% of people do not expect a reply to their review. Here is a simple way for Hawaiʻi owners to answer the good, the bad, and the unfair.

AW

AI Works Hawaii

·

3 min read

Drawing of a phone at night showing a one star review

It is Sunday night on Maui. A tour operator checks his phone and sees a new one star review: "Tour left late. Guide rushed us through the last stop."

It is Sunday night on Maui. A tour operator checks his phone and sees a new one star review: "Tour left late. Guide rushed us through the last stop."

It is Sunday night on Maui. A tour operator checks his phone and sees a new one star review: "Tour left late. Guide rushed us through the last stop."

His first reaction is to type fast and defend the crew. He puts the phone down instead.

Good call. Here is how to respond to bad Google reviews in a way that helps your business.

People expect a reply

In BrightLocal's 2025 survey of about 1,000 U.S. adults:

  • Only 7% said they do not expect a business to reply to their review.

  • Most people expect a reply within a few days to a week.

Your reply is for the reviewer. It is also for every future customer who reads it. They want to see how you treat people when something goes wrong.

A simple four step reply

  1. Thank them. Even when it stings.

  2. Name the specific problem. It shows you read it.

  3. Say what you changed. One short sentence.

  4. Give them a way to reach you. Take the rest of the talk offline.

Here is what that can look like for the tour operator:

"Thank you for telling us. You are right. We left 20 minutes late that morning, and our guide had to rush the last stop. We have moved check in earlier so the van leaves on time. Please call us at [number]. We would like to make it right."

Short. Honest. Calm. A future customer reads that and trusts the business more.

Reply to the good ones too

A five star review deserves a few words back. Use their name. Mention one detail from their visit. Thank them for choosing a local business.

When a review is unfair or fake

If a review breaks Google's rules, flag it in your Google Business Profile. Then reply once, calmly, with the facts. Do not argue in public.

Getting help with the words

Writing replies takes time. In BrightLocal's blind test, most people preferred a reply written with AI over one written by the owner. The best setup uses AI to draft, and you read and approve each reply before it posts.

ONE THING TO TRY THIS WEEK

Open your Google Business Profile. Reply to any review from the last three months that has no reply yet. Start with the oldest.

Open your Google Business Profile. Reply to any review from the last three months that has no reply yet. Start with the oldest.

Sources

  • BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2025 (1,026 U.S. adults)

Want help keeping up with replies?

Want help keeping up with replies?

Want help keeping up with replies?

Book a 15 minute call.

Let’s talk about your business

Chat with us to book a free consultation. Prefer a form? Use the short one.

Chat to book

Chat goes here.

Under construction